Checking out Porn sites

My HR issues seem to come in cycles...

Our company does a lot of volunteer work and we are currently working with High School students. They come here once a week and it was brought to my attention today that 2 weeks ago a couple of the kids were surfing porn sites.

We have already updated the computers so that this won't happen again. My question is do we notify the school and/or their parents?

Please give me your thoughts.

Thank you!

Comments

  • 28 Comments sorted by Votes Date Added
  • Not in a million years. You've been alerted to the vulnerability in your system, you've fixed it, now move on.

    Gene
  • No, that would just alienate the kids. Tell them not to do it again or you will have to notify the school and maybe the parents.
  • I would, at the very least, notify the school/teachers that coordinate the students. This is completely inappropriate!
  • 1. Be sure it was the students and not "pocket-rocket" Larry trying to blame the kids.

    2. If you are sure it is them I would tell whoever is in charge of the students at the school. I would let the school handle the parent side of it. You don't want to get caught up in the "you framed my poor innocent child" speech. Let the school handle that.

    They need to learn real quick what is/is not acceptable in a place of business. I think you'll be doing them a favor.
  • We have security cameras throughout our building - we viewed the tapes and know who it was.

    I will pass along your advice in notifying the school - I would hate for it to come back to us that we new about it and said nothing.

    Thank you!!!
  • I think saying nothing is the same as saying it is OK.

    Kids making stupid mistakes and not learning turn into adults making stupid mistakes. We've got enough of those.
  • Do you have some kind of document signed by the school and/or parents letting them know the scope of the student's responsibility, your expectations and what they can expect from you?

    If so, this might be a great place to insert a bit of language that would advise the student/parents/school of the reprecussions of inappropriate behavior. This will also protect you...and give you a step by step process for handling any future matters
  • [font size="1" color="#FF0000"]LAST EDITED ON 03-15-05 AT 02:47PM (CST)[/font][br][br]OK, now that I have been heavily overruled, I thought I might offer my rationale behind doing nothing. First of all, we're talking about HS students, not elementary school kids. This was not a "stupid mistake". It was a deliberate action taken because, well, they could. If you want to assume the duties of disciplinarian, then by all means, report it.

    Unless you've got an eye witness, simply having them on camera at the computer will create a "he did it, no it was him" fiasco. Then, there's the remote possibility that you will have to defend yourself against Johnny's mom's accusations that you did nothing to block access to such filth knowing fully well that kids would have access.

    Again, given everything on my plate and the rest of the stuff that kids are getting into today, is this worth the hassle? To me, no. You can't turn back the hands of time on this one and I'm afraid that telling the world about Johnny's affinity towards bare breasts and buttocks is not going to change a thing.

    Gene
  • Stephen, are you taking a shot at me?!?
  • [font size="1" color="#FF0000"]LAST EDITED ON 03-15-05 AT 03:23PM (CST)[/font][br][br]:oo

    It sure is hard to pretend you are working when you're laughing so hard you're crying. I haven't had a laugh like that in a long time. I have to be honest, I just came up with the name out of the blue. While I was typing I thought, " I wonder if Larry is going to chime in on this one?" And by golly, there you are.

    I would never take a shot at you Larry, you're one of the coolest guys I don't know.
  • Thanks for clarifying, Stephen. Not that I'm above doing something like that, but I don't because my young wife gives me more than I can handle.
  • Going along with Gene, I think that kids learn by telling them that what they did was not acceptable and next time (fill in the blank). This is what we do in progressive discipline and it works the vast majority of the time. If the school expects you to report it, that is another matter.
  • They were probably just being curious and showing off for their audience. I would fix it so they couldn't access the sites anymore (which you have done), but I would also have a little meeting explaining they've been caught, how disappointed you are in their behavior, that you've fixed it where they cannot access the sites anymore, and if any further attempts to do so occur (and you will know because you'll be watching), you will report it to the school and they will not be allowed to return to your facility.
  • No. Don't blabber to the school. What you did was invite adolescents into the lobby of your building and the table of magazines contained a couple of playboys and a penthouse. Why get sideways when one of them picks one up and leafs through it. Tattling to the school would accomplish nothing.

    If you give them access to your equipment, it is your job to limit access and you have learned your lesson. An admonition to the group will be sufficient. What if you had caught a couple of the guys peeking around the corner at the woman in the cubicle with the breast enhancements and short skirt? There are more productive ways to handle this positively than tattling on the students. Maybe it's a good way to tell them what is and is not acceptable in the workplace as they ready themselves to move into that arena in the next several years.

    Now, if you had caught 'Larry' with Bonnie sitting in his lap while surfing, rolling his fist skyward and chanting "YES", that might be worthy of disciplinary action from the school sponsor.

    The employer here is the guilty party, not the kids.
  • You guys are really bent on bringing me down, aren't you? I don't do porn sites anymore. I learned my lesson, did my time, and report to my parole officer weekly. But I have to admit, it's still hard to get everybody to forget the skylite incident, or the end table event in the breast feeding room. Oh well, life goes on.
  • The EMPLOYER is the guilty party? I'm suprised at you, Don.
  • Alright you guys, I think you're minimizing it a bit. Though I agree that it should not be reported if it was handled in the workplace, unless there was an agreement to report it to the school as behavior that's unacceptable.

    An "affinity towards bare breasts and buttocks" or "peeking around the corner at the woman in the cubicle with the breast enhancements and short skirt" is not (IMHO) porn. That's probably normal and conspicuous of other adults in the workplace. And - probably why businesses establish 'proper' dress code. Your business probably has standards for using the internet and email. The students should be held to the same standard as you would hold your employees. Students should be given a code of conduct, shorter but similar to what you give employees.



  • As a middle-school teacher in a former life, and the parent of two high-school students, I can tell you that I would absolutely want to know if one of my kids did something that inappropriate. I'm not saying that those kids should have their heads cut off, but doing nothing is simply giving tacit approval to their behavior, which only serves to reinforce the behavior. The point of having those kids in your building was to educate them as to how things work in a business environment. I can't think of a more appropriate lesson than to confront the goof-balls who surfed that porn site. It's part of their education.
  • I didn't notice that anybody recommended 'doing nothing'. The dilemma seemed to be whether or not to report it to the administration. My assumption is that the students were NOT told the rules, which some of you have indicated they should have been. If they were advised of the company rules, and chose to break them, then it would be appropriate to report that to their sponsor.
  • Live and learn.

    These kids are here as part of a program called Life Smarts. (we just won the state championship 2 weeks ago and we are going to San Francisco in April for nationals) That aside - it was "our bad" that we did not inform them of internet usage.

    Since we do not know if there were more than the two we caught checking out "bootie" sites we are going to speak to them as a group - which will also include "if you are caught - we will need to notify the school"

    Thank you for bringing to light a crucial part that was missing in our orientation process with these kids.

    I hope you all have a safe and happy St. Patrick's Day!!! Bottoms up! (no pun inteneded)

    x:D

  • See the first sentence in post #8, which advises doing nothing. Don, you also advised not to "blabber" to the school officials. My opinion is that kids that age don't have to be specifically told not to surf for porn sites while visiting a place of business. It's not only common sense, I'm sure it's standard procedure at their school. Computer usage is not confined to businesses. If I were the teacher sponsoring that program I would darn sure want to know who the knuckleheads were who did that, because their actions could jeopardize a program that's valuable to the other students. As an educator, I would want to know who did it because if you act like a knucklehead and no one corrects you you're pretty much gonna stay a knucklehead. As a parent, I would want to know if MY kid did it for the same reason as in the previous sentence. It’s called “accountability” and if you don’t learn it when you’re young, you’ll never learn it.


  • >See the first sentence in post #8, which advises
    >doing nothing. Don, you also advised not to
    >"blabber" to the school officials. My opinion
    >is that kids that age don't have to be
    >specifically told not to surf for porn sites
    >while visiting a place of business. It's not
    >only common sense, I'm sure it's standard
    >procedure at their school. Computer usage is
    >not confined to businesses. If I were the
    >teacher sponsoring that program I would darn
    >sure want to know who the knuckleheads were who
    >did that, because their actions could jeopardize
    >a program that's valuable to the other students.
    > As an educator, I would want to know who did it
    >because if you act like a knucklehead and no one
    >corrects you you're pretty much gonna stay a
    >knucklehead. As a parent, I would want to know
    >if MY kid did it for the same reason as in the
    >previous sentence. It’s called “accountability”
    >and if you don’t learn it when you’re young,
    >you’ll never learn it.
    >
    >


    Exactly.
  • You will not find in any of my posts that I advised doing nothing. As a previous educator, I am certain that you have the keen ability to scan the written word in paragraph form. Doing so, you will find that I advised to not blabber or tattle to the school. I did however, also advise admonishing the group as a whole, which, as I understand it, is the approach they have decided to use.

    Educators are all about control. Most educators are control freaks. It comes through in your posts. As an educator you would darn sure want to know who the knuckleheads were....yada yada. Would it not be more appropriate to say, As an educator, I feel I have a right to know if one of my students has been disruptive, acted inappropriately or jeopardized one of our educational programs so I can deal positively with those behaviors and properly guide the student?

    There are a variety of approaches to changing behavior and getting people (even youngsters) to see the error of their ways. Tattling on them is not always the best answer. Changing the students' behavior and increasing their awareness of acceptable workplace behaviors is the goal here (I assume), not giving the teacher a greater sense of the power of control. My guess is had the teacher been tattled to, the students would have been sanctioned by either removing them from the class, flunking them, having them sit in suspension or study hall, giving them a zero for the day or perhaps expelling them altogether. Those are typical educational institution responses. The employer admonishing the group or the several involved will have a more positive, more lasting effect and will go with the students the rest of their lives. (This is simply the opinion of a simple minded person who never could behave in school).
  • Never COULD behave in school, or never WOULD? And where's my "Peace" at the end of your post? I think I've earned it. Hey, if I were a control freak I wouldn't have lasted more than five minutes in my marriage. Not to belabor the point, but I do think classroom environments need to be structured in order to facilitate learning. If that makes me a "freak," I guess I'm guilty. I would have thought you might agree. Don't tell me you're a closet liberal when it comes to education.
  • I do agree (to an extent) with both sides of this debate - but I do feel personal feelings squeezed themselves into it.

    Bottom line... We ALL have done things that we PRAYED at night our parents would not find out about. Whether they were right or wrong we did not want to get busted for it. (you all are going down memory lane right now, arent' you?)

    And just think - we didn't turn out to be bad people. Ok, maybe that's pushing it! x0:)

    So, with that said, wipe out your personal feelings (those with children) do you REALLY think I should notify the school and/or the parents?

    I still am sticking by my answer of just having a meeting with them - but I thought I would just flip in my two cents based on the responses received...

    Be safe!




  • As you are the one dealing with the situation, you need to do what you feel is right. If these are generally good kids who don't normally get in trouble, you might do one thing. If they're difficult kids, you might want to do something else. I'd say go with your gut feeling. What do you think is the best for all involved? (And I'm one who wanted to know what the kids did). If you feel good about working it out with just the kids, then do that. I'm sure I don't get a call every time my daughters don't act the way I want them to. Oh,and I did walk down memory lane, and if my mom had ever gotten a call from a teacher, I wouldn't be here right now!
  • I have two children who have recently graduated from college. I do not think I would want a teacher calling me rattling on about how my 15 year old had accessed an inappropriate website. I do feel a better solution for all involved, especially my child, would be for a caring worksite sponsor to have taken him/her under their wing and 'bust him' affectionately and let him/her know it was entirely inappropriate and would not be tolerated.

    When I was 14 I busted a raw egg on the front seat of a convertible thinking it was an enemy of mine. Come to find out it was a man's car who was one of the owner's of the lumber company in my town. He called me and had me walk all the way from my house to have a conversation with him in his office. I have never forgotten that. He could easily have called my dad who would have whipped my butt and accomplished nothing. As it was, I learned a lesson and also had to wash the man's car for three weeks.
  • No. Far from a closet liberal. Where the hell did that come from? x:-) Peace.
Sign In or Register to comment.