Hiring
ILBanker
10 Posts
We are considering changing the way we approach the hiring process. The department managers currently conduct the interviews and make hiring recommendations to CEO. We have had a significant increase in turnover in the past couple of years. In the past I have suggested a team approach to hiring; the manager, HR and possibly another member of management conducting interviews and making the recommendation. CEO has been hesitant to change in the past but now wants to look at doing something different. My question is, do any of you have experience with the team approach? If so, can you give me some pros and cons of making this change?
Comments
The CEO has always gotten an opportunity to interview and state his/her feelings but to make the hiring decision, that should be left to the Department Head to whom the new employee will be receiving his/her leadership.
The CEO/COO/CFO/VP/PRESIDENTs should all back out of the picture and the burden of making the right choice. If they have a particular personal knowledge of the character or background of anyone of the candidates they should let it be known to stop any error that might happen.
I certainly don't blame the CEO for wanting to do a different approach.
Have you done exit interviews to find out why the turnover is happening. It may have nothing to do with the current procedure, except for the confusing chain of concern caused by the CEO is the final hiring authority. The department heads have got the easy street to walk!
PORK
For the most part this has worked well, not a sure fire guarantee, but being prepared has certainly help with retention.
Mostly though aside from experience and education its good ole "gut instinct".
Good luck
PORK
The next step is to give the hiring manager the applications/resumes. The department decides who gets the interviews.
Following that, the department narrows it down to 3-4 candidates. HR then conducts reference and background checks and provides a reccomendation to the Dept. Then an offer is made.
Our CEO has little to do with this process, unless we are hiring an upper level person. The rank and file hardly enter his radar!